You've got a leaky roof, a cracked foundation, or a kitchen that's seen better days. You need to hire someone, but you have no idea who to trust, and frankly, you're tired of wading through fake five-star reviews and Instagram-perfect testimonials that tell you nothing real.
This checklist exists because real hiring decisions don't happen on review sites. They happen in conversation, on job sites, and through the small details that separate someone who will actually show up from someone who won't.
Here's what you need to know about online reviews: they're not useless, but they're heavily manipulated. Contractors know this. The ones worth hiring often have fewer reviews because they don't ask every single customer to leave one, and they don't use review farms. The ones with suspiciously perfect ratings may have paid for management services that bury complaints or respond aggressively to criticism.
Use reviews as a starting point only. Look for patterns in what people actually complain about (Do they mention communication issues? Budget overruns? Unfinished work?). But treat a 4.7-star rating the same way you'd treat marketing copy, because that's what it increasingly is.
The real information comes from talking directly to the contractor and checking a few hard facts.
Before you call, text, or email, know what you're looking for. This isn't about being difficult; it's about filtering out people who won't be a good fit before you waste time.
License and insurance verification. Call your local licensing board or check their online registry. Ask for proof of general liability and workers' compensation insurance. A contractor who hesitates or says "I'll send it later" is someone to skip. Get the policy numbers and verify directly with the insurance company if you're spending more than a few thousand dollars. This is non-negotiable.
Ask about their last three projects. Not to be friendly, but to get names and phone numbers of actual customers. Ideally, recent ones. Call them. Ask specific questions: "Did they start on time? Did the final bill match the estimate? Would you hire them again?" Listen for hesitation or vague answers. Real homeowners give real answers.
Request a written estimate. Not a verbal quote. Not a text message. A written estimate that breaks down labor, materials, and timeline. If they won't provide one, move on. A vague estimate is how you end up with surprise costs.
Confirm they're actually available. Some contractors are booked months out and will take your job knowing they can't prioritize it. Ask when they can start and when they expect to finish. Get specifics. "Spring sometime" is not an answer.
Trust your gut on communication. Were they responsive to your initial inquiry? Did they ask clarifying questions or just start quoting? Do you understand what they're proposing? If someone is hard to reach before you hire them, they'll be invisible during the job.
You'll get more useful information in a ten-minute conversation than from hours of scrolling reviews. Here's what to actually listen for:
When you describe your project, does the contractor ask questions or jump straight to solutions? The ones asking questions are thinking about your specific situation. The ones that immediately suggest a fix are operating from a template.
Ask them to describe the trickiest part of your job. A competent contractor will identify real challenges. Someone vague or dismissive hasn't thought it through.
Pay attention to how they talk about previous jobs and previous clients. Professionals criticize their own work or past decisions. Contractors who blame every problem on homeowners or other trades, or who refuse to acknowledge anything they'd do differently, are signaling something.
Finally, ask how they handle problems when they come up, because they will. You want to hear that they contact the homeowner immediately, document things, and work toward a solution. You don't want to hear that they'll "handle it" without your input.
Save time by recognizing these red flags early:
The last one matters more than people think. If you can't get someone on the phone before you hire them, you're setting yourself up for months of one-way text conversations about your home.
Once you've narrowed it to two or three contractors who pass the checklist, put their written estimates side by side. The goal isn't to find the cheapest option; it's to understand what you're actually paying for.
Do they all include the same scope of work? Are they using the same materials? Is one contractor doing demolition and disposal while another expects you to handle it? These differences explain price variance. A contractor who's $2,000 cheaper but skipped disposal is quoting you a different job.
Talk to each one about warranty and what happens if something fails six months later. Their answers should be clear and in writing.
After you've worked through the checklist and the phone calls and the estimate comparisons, step back. You'll usually know who you trust. That feeling is based on whether someone answered your questions directly, whether they were interested in your project for real reasons, whether they communicated like an adult, and whether they seemed to care about doing good work.
Hire that person. The cheapest quote or the most five-star reviews won't matter if the contractor doesn't show up on time or disappears when problems arise.
Before you sign anything, send an email summarizing what you understood: the scope of work, the start date, the expected end date, the total cost, and what happens if either side needs to change course. Ask them to confirm in writing that you've both got the same understanding. This single step prevents most disputes.
You're about to let someone into your home and give them money. Five minutes of basic due diligence protects you in ways that reviews never will.
Get more like this in the weekly letter — subscribe at /.
← All posts