A fence is one of the few home projects where the finished product sits on your property line, in public view, for fifteen or twenty years. The gap between a good install and a sloppy one is not obvious the week the crew leaves. It shows up two winters later, in leaning posts and gates that no longer latch. Here is how to hire well the first time.
Why quotes for the same fence vary so much
Three estimates for the same yard routinely come back thousands of dollars apart, and it is rarely because one contractor is dishonest. Fence pricing is driven by linear footage first, but the multipliers hide underneath: how many gates you want, whether an old fence has to come out and be hauled away, how much of the run is on a slope, what the soil is like where the posts go, and how far the crew has to carry material from the truck. A quote that seems high may simply be the only one that priced the tear-out. Always ask each bidder to break the number into materials, labor, tear-out, and haul-away so you are comparing the same job.
Picking a material that fits the Mid-Atlantic
Pressure-treated wood is the budget standard and takes stain well, but in the humid summers along the Delaware and Chesapeake coasts it wants maintenance: plan on cleaning and re-sealing every few years, and expect some boards to move as they dry. Cedar resists rot naturally and ages to a gray that many people like, at a higher price per foot. Vinyl costs more up front, never needs paint, and shrugs off humidity, which is why it has taken over so many shore-area neighborhoods; its weakness is impact damage and the fact that a cracked panel gets replaced, not repaired. Aluminum is the low-maintenance pick where you want the look of iron without the rust, and it handles salt air far better than steel. Chain link remains the value option for containment jobs where looks are secondary. If your lot catches coastal wind, ask specifically what post depth and footing the installer uses, because wind load, not gravity, is what tips fences.
The 7 questions that matter
1. Are you licensed and insured, and can I see both? Any legitimate contractor expects this question. You want general liability at minimum, and workers' compensation if a crew is coming.
2. Who confirms the property line? Fences built a foot onto a neighbor's land get expensive. If you do not have a recent survey, ask whether the installer requires one or works from pins. A contractor who shrugs at this question is a red flag.
3. Do I need a permit or approval? Requirements vary by county and municipality, and many homeowners associations have their own height, style, and setback rules. A good local installer knows the drill for your area; confirm in writing who is responsible for securing any permit before work starts.
4. What exactly is in the written scope? Post spacing, post depth, concrete or gravel footings, gate hardware brand, cleanup, and haul-away should all be on paper. Verbal promises do not survive a busy season.
5. How is the warranty split? Material warranties come from the manufacturer; workmanship warranties come from the installer. Ask for both, in writing, and ask what the workmanship warranty actually covers: leaning posts, sagging gates, and panel movement are the usual failure points.
6. What is the realistic timeline? Spring is fence season, and good crews book out weeks ahead. A very short lead time in April can be a sign of an empty calendar, and an empty calendar has causes.
7. What happens to the old fence and the dirt? Post holes produce more spoil than people expect. Cleanup and disposal should be in the quote, not discovered at the end.
Red flags worth walking away from
A demand for full payment up front. No physical address or truck lettering. A quote dramatically below every other bid, which usually means shallow posts, no concrete, or a crew that will not be around when the gate sags. And pressure to skip the permit conversation, which puts the fine on you, not them.
Timing your project
Late fall and winter are the sleeper seasons for fence work in the Mid-Atlantic. The ground rarely freezes hard for long, crews are hungrier, and you skip the spring queue. If your project can wait for November, the same fence often costs less and starts sooner.
Greenville, DE · Dover, DE · Newark, DE · Wilmington, DE · all fence contractors