Hiring the wrong type of worker for a given job is how homeowners end up in two common bad spots: paying a contractor $400 for a job a handyman would've done for $100, or hiring a handyman for work that voids your insurance and the city won't sign off on. Here's the breakdown.
What each type is
Licensed contractor , Passed a state exam, carries required insurance and bonding, registered with state consumer affairs office. Can legally pull permits, do work subject to inspection, and perform trade-specific jobs (electrical, plumbing, HVAC, structural).
Handyman , A skilled generalist. No state license requirement for small jobs under a dollar threshold (varies by state: $1,000 in Delaware, $5,000 in Pennsylvania for non-structural work). Typically carries general liability insurance but not trade-specific licenses.
Jobs that legally require a licensed contractor
In most Mid-Atlantic states:
- Any electrical work beyond replacing like-for-like fixtures
- Any plumbing work on supply lines or drain lines (fixture swaps are gray area)
- Any HVAC refrigerant work (federal EPA 608 certification required)
- Any structural work (bearing walls, joists, roof framing)
- Any permitted work (kitchen/bath remodels, additions, new windows in most municipalities)
- Any gas line work (all states)
- Roof replacements in most states
Jobs a handyman can legally handle
- Drywall patching
- Interior painting
- Furniture assembly and mounting
- Fence and gate repair (not install over a certain height)
- Replace a light fixture (existing box, same location)
- Swap a dimmer or switch
- Change a faucet (existing supply lines and drain)
- Fix a running toilet
- Garbage disposal replacement
- Weather-stripping, caulking, screen repair
- Minor trim carpentry and molding
- Install shelving, blinds, or curtain rods
- Pressure washing
- Gutter cleaning
- Small deck repair (not new deck builds)
The gray zones
Some jobs are legally a handyman's to do, but quality risk is high:
- Tile repair (handyman OK; full tile install should be a pro)
- Cabinet installation (handyman OK for pre-built; custom work needs a cabinetmaker)
- Small flooring repair (OK); whole-room install (hire a flooring contractor)
- Roof patching (tarp and caulk only; actual repair needs a roofer for warranty and insurance reasons)
Why the license matters beyond legality
- Insurance claims. If your unlicensed handyman does electrical work and your house burns down, your insurance will deny the claim. The permit status and licensed-contractor signature matter to insurers.
- Resale disclosure. Non-permitted work must be disclosed when you sell. Unpermitted kitchen remodels and additions are a major resale issue.
- Inspections. Licensed work gets inspected. A bad install by a licensed contractor can be caught before you use the system for 10 years and find out about the problem the hard way.
- Warranty and recourse. If an unlicensed handyman does bad work, your recourse is almost zero. Licensed contractors have bonds and insurance you can claim against.
Cost comparison (typical)
| Job | Handyman | Licensed pro |
|---|---|---|
| Replace a light fixture | $75-125 | $125-250 |
| Mount a TV | $100-200 | (not their job) |
| Install ceiling fan, existing box | $125-200 | $175-300 |
| New ceiling fan circuit | (cannot do) | $400-700 |
| Faucet replacement | $125-200 | $175-275 |
| Toilet replacement | $150-250 | $250-400 |
| Drywall patch (small) | $75-150 | (overkill) |
| Paint a room | $250-400 | $350-600 |
Browse PicksByTown directories
Handyman services · Electricians · Plumbers · General contractors